1. A defined question and contribution
Identify the physical question, the purpose of the paper, and what it adds. Work should fall within the journal’s scope: alternative theoretical physics and related mathematical, computational, or experimental investigations. Original results, critical analyses, replication studies, and well-supported negative results can all make a contribution.
2. Explicit assumptions and a traceable argument
Define the concepts, symbols, units, assumptions, and limits needed to follow the central reasoning. A claimed derivation must contain enough intermediate reasoning to assess whether the conclusion follows. A proposed principle should be distinguished from a result derived from that principle.
Review should address the author’s actual objective. Requests for additional models or calculations should be justified by claims the paper makes, rather than by a different research objective imposed during review.
3. Evidence appropriate to the claim
Mathematical claims need checkable reasoning. Numerical claims need enough information about inputs, methods, and outputs to assess or reproduce the central calculation. Experimental claims need an adequate description of the apparatus, procedure, measurements, and relevant controls and uncertainties.
A theoretical proposal need not already have experimental confirmation to be considered. It must make clear what is established, what depends on assumptions, and what remains a conjecture or proposed test. An observation alone does not establish a proposed mechanism.
4. Conclusions that match the work
State the domain and limitations of the result. Distinguish new predictions from fitted values, established results from reinterpretations, and demonstrated findings from speculation. Claims of equivalence, contradiction, or a solution to an existing problem require support for that specific claim.
Disagreement with a conventional model is not itself a reason for rejection. The paper must explain the point of departure and provide reasoning or evidence that can be examined.
5. Clear attribution and responsible authorship
Identify ideas, quotations, figures, data, and results taken from other work. Submit only material you have permission to share, with all coauthors’ agreement. Disclose relevant prior publication, funding, conflicts of interest, and substantive AI assistance to the editor.
A formal reference list, acknowledgments, and a separate declarations page are encouraged. Their absence alone does not automatically exclude a manuscript. Attribution needed to distinguish original work from borrowed material, and disclosures relevant to assessment, are still expected.
6. Substantive review concerns addressed
Before acceptance, material objections must be resolved or answered with a reasoned, assessable response. Authors may disagree with a review finding and explain why. New journal submissions require a completed review and a recorded editorial acceptance decision.
What “conditional” means
An invitation to revise identifies the outstanding conditions for further consideration. It is not a promise of acceptance. The revised work and the response to the stated concerns are assessed before a final decision.
Formatting preferences, voluntary gifts, and the purchase of author services do not determine scientific acceptance.